A friend was trying to answer a question about the Bible for someone. I said, “what I would do is…” and explained a process for understanding the text. I realized you might be interested, too.
1. Sometimes there is mystery. I’m listening to a seminary class these days and John Goldingay, the prof, said “I don’t know answers to questions the Bible doesn’t know the answer to.” I loved that. There are times we don’t know the answer, that we just can’t get to a clear, simple answer.
2. I look at 2-3 translations. I use a word-by-word version like the ESV or NASB, a thought-by-thought like the NIV and a paraphrase of ideas like The Message. Biblegateway.com makes this easy.
3. I look at the context of the whole book (e.g Matthew, Colossians) and all the works by the writer (e.g. Paul, John) and the whole Bible. Obviously, for every sentence I can’t read the whole Bible again. But I do look for how a writer uses that idea in other places.
4. I ask the Author. I assume that God is behind these words, both as they were written and as I am understanding them. So I ask for clarity. (Just like you may ask me questions about something I write here.)
5. I look at commentaries, books that walk through the text and explain it. Good ones (like this one on Matthew) describe what other scholars have said.
6. I look at what other scholars have said. If we look at Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, Calvin, Wesley, Barth, and Carson, we have 1700 years of scholarship across many denominations. Where they agree, that’s probably what the text means. Where they disagree, the issue may be a secondary issue.
These steps can time and work. And you may think, “I’ll just ask Jon. He can do this.” That’s fine. But sometimes it’s worth the work.
—
I did an extended version of this post on video: 300wordsaday – understanding the text
Todd Lohenry
Ask the author. Brilliant!!!
LikeLike
Rich Dixon
Maybe if it’s not worth the effort to dig out the meaning, the question doesn’t really matter as much as you imagined. This old teacher used this as a filter when students “had to know” an answer, as long as someone else did the work to discover it. Maybe God does that, also. Maybe His willingness to help is somehow proportional to my willingness to listen and learn and study.
I love the notion that if those who’ve devoted their lives to Jesus disagree on an issue, perhaps that issue isn’t at the heart of Jesus’ teaching. I’ve always thought that if you gathered all the pastors in a city and compiled a list of what they all AGREE about (not the fine points of their theological disagreements) you’d likely have the heart of the gospel and a direction in which they could lead together to serve and expand the circle instead of competing.for those already inside.
LikeLike
Cheryl
I totally agree, but why is it that doesn’t happen very often?
LikeLike
Jon Swanson
well said, Rich. And thanks for the post you just gave me.
LikeLike